TLDR
- British man James Howells’ legal battle to recover $740 million worth of Bitcoin from a landfill has ended in defeat
- He accidentally threw away a hard drive containing 8,000 Bitcoin in 2013
- A Welsh judge ruled that the case had no reasonable grounds for success
- Newport City Council has blocked recovery attempts due to environmental concerns
- The Bitcoin, originally worth $1.3M when lost, has increased in value to $740M as Bitcoin hit $108,000
A UK judge has ended a British man’s hopes of recovering a hard drive containing 8,000 Bitcoin from a Welsh landfill, bringing a close to a 12-year saga that spans the evolution of cryptocurrency from obscurity to mainstream finance.
The case, which concluded on January 10, 2025, centered around IT professional James Howells and a mistaken decision during a house cleanup in 2013 that would prove extremely costly. Howells had two identical hard drives at his home – one empty and one containing Bitcoin he had mined in 2009 when the cryptocurrency was in its infancy.
In what would become an expensive mix-up, Howells accidentally discarded the drive containing his Bitcoin stash. His girlfriend at the time took out the garbage, unknowingly carrying a fortune to the local waste facility. When the mistake was discovered, the Bitcoin was worth about $1.3 million – a sum that would have seemed substantial at the time.
What followed was more than a decade of increasingly desperate attempts to convince Newport City Council to allow a search of the Docksway landfill site. Howells identified the likely location of the hard drive as Cell 2, Area 2 of the facility, but council officials remained unmoved by his requests.
The story took a legal turn when Howells filed a lawsuit against the council seeking $646 million in damages. His legal team presented plans for a careful excavation of the site, including proposals to modernize the landfill facilities and share recovered funds with the local community.
Newport City Council maintained its position throughout the years, consistently citing environmental protection as the primary reason for denying access. Officials expressed concerns about the potential impact of excavation on the surrounding area and local ecosystem.
Judge Keyser KC, serving as the Circuit Commercial Judge for Wales, delivered the final blow to Howells’ recovery hopes. The judge determined there were no “reasonable grounds” for the case to proceed to a full trial, effectively ending the legal avenue for recovery.
The ruling left Howells visibly frustrated. “It’s the great British justice system striking again,” he commented after hearing the decision, adding that he felt “very upset” about the outcome. His disappointment was compounded by recent developments in the cryptocurrency market.
The timing of the court’s decision proved particularly painful as Bitcoin had just reached unprecedented heights. The cryptocurrency broke through the $100,000 barrier in December 2024, eventually climbing above $108,000. At these prices, Howells’ lost 8,000 Bitcoin would be worth approximately $740 million.
Throughout the dispute, Howells attempted various approaches to gain access to the landfill. His team developed detailed plans for the search operation, promising to conduct the excavation with minimal environmental impact. They argued that recovering even 10% of the Bitcoin could provide substantial benefits to the Newport community.
The case has drawn attention to the unique challenges of digital asset recovery, particularly when physical storage devices end up in waste management facilities. Unlike traditional valuable items, recovering digital assets requires both finding the physical device and ensuring its data remains intact.
For twelve years, Howells tried to engage with the council, presenting increasingly sophisticated proposals for the recovery operation. Despite his persistence, he claims he was “largely ignored” by local authorities throughout the process.
The council’s environmental concerns remained the primary obstacle. Despite Howells’ offers to modernize the landfill and implement environmentally conscious recovery methods, officials maintained their position against allowing any excavation of the site.
Court documents confirmed the specific location of the hard drive within the landfill, but this information proved insufficient to overcome the legal and environmental hurdles. The judge’s ruling suggests that even knowing the exact location of lost digital assets may not guarantee recovery rights.
The January 2025 court decision appears to mark the end of the road for Howells’ recovery efforts, leaving his Bitcoin fortune buried in the Welsh landfill, likely permanently beyond reach.
Stay Ahead of the Market with Benzinga Pro!
Want to trade like a pro? Benzinga Pro gives you the edge you need in today's fast-paced markets. Get real-time news, exclusive insights, and powerful tools trusted by professional traders:
- Breaking market-moving stories before they hit mainstream media
- Live audio squawk for hands-free market updates
- Advanced stock scanner to spot promising trades
- Expert trade ideas and on-demand support
