TLDR:
- Piper Sandler reduced Tesla’s price target from $450 to $400 while maintaining an Overweight rating
- Tesla’s Q1 deliveries of 337,000 fell short of the 378,000 consensus estimate
- US sales dropped 9% year-over-year, while China sales grew slightly by 2%
- Recent Chinese weekly sales dropped 15% as US-China trade tensions escalate
- Q1 earnings report expected on April 22 with potential margin pressure
Tesla is facing multiple headwinds as Piper Sandler cut its stock price target from $450 to $400 on Wednesday. The investment firm maintained its Overweight rating despite concerns over the electric vehicle maker’s first-quarter financial performance.
Tesla delivered 337,000 vehicles in the first quarter, significantly below the consensus estimate of 378,000 units. This shortfall has raised questions about the company’s ability to maintain its growth trajectory in the increasingly competitive electric vehicle market.
In the United States, Tesla sold approximately 128,000 cars during Q1, representing a 9% decrease compared to the same period last year. The company’s market share in the US has declined from about 53% to 43%, suggesting increased competition from other manufacturers.
The situation appears somewhat better in China, where Tesla managed to sell 135,000 vehicles in the first quarter. This represents a modest 2% increase year-over-year despite sales disruptions related to the Model Y refresh, which temporarily slowed purchases as customers waited for the updated version.
However, recent weekly sales data from China has shown a concerning 15% drop. While this represents just one week of data, analysts note that the decline coincides with escalating trade tensions between the United States and China.
Trade War Concerns
The deteriorating US-China trade relationship under President Trump’s administration may be creating new challenges for Tesla in the Chinese market. There are emerging signs that Chinese consumers might be shifting their preferences toward domestic brands like BYD.
“You’re seeing some consumers in China now choosing BYD vehicles over Teslas,” noted Cantor Fitzgerald analyst Andres Sheppard. “There’s now the sentiment in China that they’re essentially encouraging the consumer to purchase non-American products, or in this case, Chinese products.”
This trend is particularly worrisome for Tesla investors given that China represents more than 20% of the company’s 2024 revenue. China remains the world’s largest market for both conventional vehicles and electric vehicles, making it a crucial component of Tesla’s global strategy.
The potential for a Chinese consumer boycott of American products adds another layer of uncertainty for Tesla as it prepares to announce its first-quarter earnings on April 22.
Financial Outlook and Margins
Financial analysts are expressing concern about Tesla’s margins in the upcoming earnings report. InvestingPro data shows the company’s gross profit margin stands at 17.86%, while it maintains a high P/E ratio of 113.57.
Twelve analysts have recently revised their earnings estimates downward for Tesla, suggesting widespread pessimism about the company’s short-term financial performance. The absence of clear information regarding Tesla’s upcoming “Model 2” has contributed to this uncertainty.
Without disclosed specifications or pricing for the new model, projections for Tesla’s delivery growth have become more challenging to formulate. This lack of clarity has prompted Piper Sandler to revise its estimates for the automaker, though they note that Tesla remains profitable with $97.69 billion in trailing twelve-month revenue.
Despite these concerns, Piper Sandler maintains a bullish long-term outlook for Tesla. The firm reminds investors that Tesla has historically experienced sharp rallies triggered by significant developments, particularly those related to new products and technological advancements.
Future Catalysts
Looking beyond immediate challenges, several potential catalysts could positively impact Tesla’s performance in the future. Piper Sandler specifically points to forthcoming products and the advancement of robo-taxis as major developments that could drive stock appreciation.
While the upcoming Q1 earnings call may not present these developments, good news on these fronts is expected eventually. This suggests that despite near-term bearishness for the next two to three months, the long-term outlook remains positive.
Cantor Fitzgerald, which rates Tesla shares as Buy with a $425 price target, highlights several upcoming catalysts including the new lower-priced model, the planned robotaxi service, and eventually sales of AI-trained robots. These developments could potentially drive shares higher once the market moves past the first-quarter disappointment.
Tesla investors are advised to maintain awareness of the company’s “big picture” prospects, as these major initiatives could deliver positive surprises that offset current challenges.
The company has faced other recent incidents, including arson attacks on a Tesla dealership in New Mexico that damaged two Model Y vehicles. Despite these events, many analysts have maintained a positive outlook on Tesla’s stock.
Tesla’s Q1 earnings report, scheduled for April 22, will provide more clarity on the company’s financial position and its strategy for addressing the challenges in both the US and Chinese markets.
Stay Ahead of the Market with Benzinga Pro!
Want to trade like a pro? Benzinga Pro gives you the edge you need in today's fast-paced markets. Get real-time news, exclusive insights, and powerful tools trusted by professional traders:
- Breaking market-moving stories before they hit mainstream media
- Live audio squawk for hands-free market updates
- Advanced stock scanner to spot promising trades
- Expert trade ideas and on-demand support
