TLDR
- Texas judge orders Bitcoin investor Frank Ahlgren III to surrender crypto keys to $124M fortune
- Ahlgren failed to report $3.7M in Bitcoin sales and used mixers to hide transactions
- Court ruling blocks asset transfers except for basic living costs
- Investor faces 2-year prison term plus $1M in restitution after September 2024 guilty plea
- Case highlights growing IRS success in tracking crypto tax evasion
A Texas federal court has told early Bitcoin investor Frank Richard Ahlgren III he must hand over the keys to his cryptocurrency fortune. The January 2025 ruling demands Ahlgren provide access to digital wallets holding assets worth an estimated $124 million.
Judge Robert Pitman’s order covers every aspect of Ahlgren’s crypto holdings. The investor must surrender private keys, seed phrases, and any devices storing digital currency. The court’s reach extends to Ahlgren’s inner circle, blocking friends and family from moving his assets without permission.
The roots of this case stretch back to 2015, when Bitcoin traded for less than $500. That year, Ahlgren bought 1,366 Bitcoin through his Coinbase account, making him an early player in the crypto market. His entry point proved lucky – by 2017, Bitcoin’s value had soared.
Taking advantage of the price surge, Ahlgren sold 640 Bitcoin in 2017, pocketing $3.7 million. He used the windfall to buy real estate in Park City, Utah. But when tax time came, Ahlgren’s filing raised red flags. He claimed his Bitcoin purchase prices were much higher than actual market rates, lowering his reported gains.
The deception didn’t stop there. Over the next two years, Ahlgren kept selling. He moved another $650,000 worth of Bitcoin in 2018 and 2019. These sales never showed up on his tax returns. To cover his tracks, he got creative with technology.
Ahlgren used every trick in the crypto playbook to hide his money moves. He bounced funds between multiple digital wallets, made cash trades, and ran his Bitcoin through mixing services. These tools scramble cryptocurrency transactions, making them harder to follow.
The IRS wasn’t fooled. Their investigation led to Ahlgren’s guilty plea in September 2024. The court handed down a two-year prison sentence and ordered him to pay back $1 million. After prison, he faces a year of watched freedom under supervision.
The January 2025 order puts tight limits on Ahlgren’s remaining fortune. While he can tap funds for basic living costs, everything else needs court approval. The restriction applies to anyone who might help him move money.
Lucy Tan, an Acting Special Agent with IRS Criminal Investigation, had stern words about the case. She said high crypto prices often tempt people to dodge taxes. But Ahlgren’s story shows even digital currency leaves a trail.
“Ahlgren will serve time because he thought crypto transactions couldn’t be traced,” Tan said. “This case proves everyone must follow the law.”
Bill Hughes, a lawyer at blockchain company Consensys, explained what the ruling means for crypto owners. While self-custody gives users control of their coins, he said, the government can still seize assets when tax laws are broken.
The case shows how far crypto tax enforcement has come. Early Bitcoin users thought digital money would stay under the radar. Now, the IRS has tools to spot unreported crypto income.
Judge Pitman’s order takes special care to lock down Ahlgren’s assets. Besides demanding wallet access, it stops any value-dropping moves. This protects the government’s ability to collect what it’s owed.
The ruling proves paper laws still bind digital money. Despite cryptocurrency’s independent design, courts can force holders to give up control when they break tax rules.
Ahlgren started his crypto journey in 2011, riding Bitcoin’s early waves. But his attempt to avoid taxes in 2015 and beyond led to his downfall. Now he must open his digital vaults to the same system he tried to evade.
The fact that Bitcoin transactions happen on public ledgers helped the case. While mixing services can blur the picture, investigators can often still piece together the money trail. This makes tax evasion harder than many early crypto users expected.
Stay Ahead of the Market with Benzinga Pro!
Want to trade like a pro? Benzinga Pro gives you the edge you need in today's fast-paced markets. Get real-time news, exclusive insights, and powerful tools trusted by professional traders:
- Breaking market-moving stories before they hit mainstream media
- Live audio squawk for hands-free market updates
- Advanced stock scanner to spot promising trades
- Expert trade ideas and on-demand support
