TLDR
- DOJ is pursuing two antitrust lawsuits against Google, targeting its search monopoly and adtech dominance
- Potential remedies include divestiture of Chrome browser, Android platform, and forcing data sharing with competitors
- Google derives over 75% of its revenue ($265 billion) from advertising, with search advertising being its primary income source
- Historical precedents like Standard Oil and AT&T suggest the DOJ has the power to break up dominant companies
- A potential breakup might actually benefit shareholders, as broken-up companies often outperform conglomerates due to the “diversification discount”
Alphabet Inc., Google’s parent company, faces mounting pressure from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) as antitrust lawsuits progress that could potentially reshape the tech giant. The DOJ is advancing two separate cases against Google. One targets its search engine monopoly while the other focuses on its dominance in the advertising technology market.
The search engine case, first filed in 2020, has now entered the remedies phase. In this stage, the court will determine appropriate measures to prevent Google from further monopolizing the search market.
Proposed remedies could be far-reaching. They may include forcing Google to divest its Chrome browser or Android platform. Other options include prohibiting exclusive agreements with smartphone manufacturers that make Google the default search engine on billions of devices.
The DOJ also argues that Google uses AI to extend its dominance. This happens through zero-click searches with AI-generated answers from Gemini and by preferencing its own services in search results.
Google executives have confirmed they intend to fight these proposals in court. The company claims the DOJ’s suggested actions could harm U.S. consumers and the nation’s technological leadership in key areas like AI.
Historical Precedents Suggest Real Threat
Investors should not underestimate the regulatory threat Google faces. The DOJ has a history of breaking up dominant companies found to violate antitrust laws.
In 1911, the DOJ ordered the breakup of Standard Oil into 34 independent companies. Modern oil giants like Exxon Mobil and Chevron were once part of Standard Oil before this forced separation.
More recently, in 1982, the DOJ forced AT&T to divest its local telephone business into seven regional companies. This action aimed to ensure fair competition in the telecommunications sector.
These historical examples demonstrate the DOJ’s power to restructure dominant companies. Today’s market dynamics add another layer of risk, as even rumors of regulatory action could drive significant stock volatility.
Google’s heavy reliance on advertising revenue makes it particularly vulnerable to these threats. In 2024, Google reported $265 billion in advertising revenue, accounting for over 75% of its total income.
Search advertising remains Google’s most substantial revenue stream. The company generated $198 billion from this source alone last year.
If the DOJ succeeds in prohibiting Google from securing default search engine status with smartphone manufacturers like Apple, it could open doors for competitors. Users might be allowed to manually choose their preferred search engine, potentially reducing Google’s market share.
Chrome Divestiture Would Disrupt Google’s Ecosystem
A forced divestiture of Chrome would disrupt Google’s tightly integrated ecosystem. Chrome currently serves as a key intermediary connecting users to Google Search.
According to StatCounter, Chrome dominated the global web browser market as of March, with a 66.17% market share. Safari, in second place, controlled just 17.59% of the market.
The DOJ’s focus on forcing Google to share analytics data with competitors threatens the data advantage Google has maintained for decades. This could enable rivals to develop products that better compete with Google’s offerings.
Wall Street analysts currently maintain a Moderate Buy consensus rating on GOOGL stock. This is based on 29 Buy ratings and 10 Hold ratings over the past three months, with zero Sell recommendations.
The average price target for GOOGL stock is $198.59, suggesting approximately 22% upside potential over the next twelve months. However, regulatory uncertainty continues to weigh on investor sentiment.
Interestingly, a potential breakup might not be as negative for shareholders as initially feared. Academic finance theory recognizes a “diversification discount,” where conglomerates often trade at lower valuations than the sum of their individual parts.
AT&T’s 1980s breakup provides a telling historical parallel. A portfolio of the seven “Baby Bells” created from AT&T significantly outperformed the S&P 500 index over the following 15 years. In contrast, IBM, which successfully fought off a similar antitrust action, substantially underperformed during the same period.
The diversification discount occurs because markets typically allocate capital more efficiently than conglomerate management. Studies show diversified companies tend to funnel resources toward their least efficient divisions, a tendency that worsens with organizational complexity.
Alphabet’s diverse business portfolio extends far beyond its core advertising business. The company has ventured into healthcare (Verily), urban innovation (Sidewalk Labs), self-driving cars (Waymo), robotics software (Intrinsic), and commercial drone delivery (Wing), among many others.
The company maintains a complex organizational structure. Some divisions operate as separate companies under the Google subsidiary, while others are owned directly by Alphabet through its “Other Bets” unit.
For investors, the key question becomes whether Alphabet’s management can allocate capital across these diverse businesses more effectively than the market would. Historical evidence suggests this is a difficult feat for most conglomerates to achieve.
The DOJ’s antitrust cases against Google will continue to develop in the coming weeks and months. The most recent court rulings suggest regulatory pressure is increasing rather than abating.
Stay Ahead of the Market with Benzinga Pro!
Want to trade like a pro? Benzinga Pro gives you the edge you need in today's fast-paced markets. Get real-time news, exclusive insights, and powerful tools trusted by professional traders:
- Breaking market-moving stories before they hit mainstream media
- Live audio squawk for hands-free market updates
- Advanced stock scanner to spot promising trades
- Expert trade ideas and on-demand support
